I've been on these forums and DCS for little over a decade, only stopped being involved with both due to change in personal life that prevent me from continuing... but hopefully will get back into it again. I am very surprised to see this go, I saw no issue with it at all and it was for me very nice way for us, the community, to share our free will with the rest and naturally and democratically self-regulate ourselves, so to speak. I hope you bring it back, possibly make some adjustments to it so to try to prevent abuse, but I feel getting rid of it is more negative then positive.
I feel personal expression is very important, even if sometimes sounding negative, if we lose that, we lose a lot.