Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How does this plane compare to the F86 Sabre

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    How does this plane compare to the F86 Sabre

    I own the F86 Sabre but found it very difficult to fly as soon as I left the basics like taking off.
    I understand that Mig 15 is a similar plane. So how is it with regard to quality of content like missions tutorials compared to F86 ? How easy is it to fly and fight in ? I have only had time to try the startup and take off tutorial

    #2
    Originally posted by jfri View Post
    I own the F86 Sabre but found it very difficult to fly as soon as I left the basics like taking off.
    I understand that Mig 15 is a similar plane. So how is it with regard to quality of content like missions tutorials compared to F86 ?
    It is pretty similar, it has 5 training missions, 3 single missions and 23 Quick start missions (distributed on 4 Maps, many similar to each other). It has no built-in Campaign.

    For comparison, the Sabre has 9 training missions, 6 single missions and 23 Quick start missions on 4 maps. It has no built-in Campaign.

    Both are hampered by lack of period assets, and that is probably the reason why there are not many User missions for them. I edited a set for the Mig-15 and had to resort to using Mods and the WW2 Assets Pack:

    https://forums.eagle.ru/showthread.php?t=233110

    How easy is it to fly and fight in ?
    The -15 is easy to fly but hard to master, I flew it for a while, more to experience the evolution between planes like the P-51 and the early jets, rather than intending to do any multiplayer air combat.

    I have only had time to try the startup and take off tutorial
    Not good .. nothing is better than your own experience, you should take advantage of the opportunity of the current free-to-try and actually try the aircraft yourself instead of relying on someone else's opinions.

    Best regards,


    Eduardo
    For work: iMac mid-2010 of 27" - Core i7 870 - 6 GB DDR3 1333 MHz - ATI HD5670 - SSD 256 GB - HDD 2 TB - macOS High Sierra
    For Gaming: 34" Monitor - Ryzen 1500X - 32 GB DDR4 2400 - nVidia GTX1070ti - SSD 1.25 TB - HDD 10 TB - Windows 10 Pro - Thrustmaster HOTAS Cougar - Oculus Rift CV1
    Mobile: iPad Pro 12.9" of 256 GB

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by Rudel_chw View Post
      Not good .. nothing is better than your own experience, you should take advantage of the opportunity of the current free-to-try and actually try the aircraft yourself instead of relying on someone else's opinions.

      After posting this I did tried the AA gun tutorial. Here I noticed the plane was very slow in its turning and roll. Is the plane like this or has it bad performence on my computer ?
      Other planes are better in this regard.

      Comment


        #4
        The aircraft was known to have a reasonably slow roll rate as compared to the Sabre. It's particularly bad at the higher speeds. MiG 15 does well in climb against the Sabre although it's worth noting it wasn't supposed to be that much better than the F model Sabre but in game it does still seem to outclimb it.

        The MiGs party trick is acceleration, so boom and zoom tactics are your best bet. You're going to struggle to out turn an AI F86 (or at least I do).

        I recently bought both the F86 and the MiG 15. I like the MiG more but from a game point of view, it doesn't really have enough content I certainly only got it because it was on sale.

        Comment


          #5
          acceleration is good but 'boom and zoom' is not how you abuse acceleration
          mig is terrible at high speeds, do not dive with it
          roll is mediocre to bad depending on speed, but pitch rates should be snappy

          the sabre is already an easy aircraft but if you can't handle even that then dont expect to catch a break with the mig
          hahaha hey look at me i surely know more about aviation and coding than actual industry professionals hired for their competency because i have read jalopnik and wikipedia i bet theyve never even heard of google LOL

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by probad View Post
            acceleration is good but 'boom and zoom' is not how you abuse acceleration
            mig is terrible at high speeds, do not dive with it
            roll is mediocre to bad depending on speed, but pitch rates should be snappy

            the sabre is already an easy aircraft but if you can't handle even that then dont expect to catch a break with the mig

            I would say the roll is terrible slow compared to even the other Migs. And the Mig is fighter right ? Then how can it survive in dogfight when turning is so slow ?
            Regarding the F86 Sabre feeling difficult. Made that judgement only after trying the navigation session a couple of times and found keeping the altitude difficult. Maybe with a bit of more exercise and patient I might change my mind about it.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by jfri View Post
              I would say the roll is terrible slow compared to even the other Migs. And the Mig is fighter right ? Then how can it survive in dogfight when turning is so slow ?...
              How Bf-109 can survive against I-16 turning so slow?

              For Mig-15 the primary target was B-29, not F-86 or F-84.

              Comment


                #8
                I eat AI sabres for breakfast in my MiG. Literally, the nevada dogfight instant action is my daily dose of BFM.

                The MiG is not an easy plane. It will stall. It will mach tuck. It will drop wings at inopportune moments. She does seem to have a little more power than the sabre, but not enough to extend at will from them. You need to fly it with care, attention, patience and no small dose of luck.

                The best thing about the MiG are the guns however. Such fun. No pansy ratatat, but two big honking 23mm Soviet hate dispensers with a 37mm cyka blyat blyat gun thrown in for good measure. One hit from that and it's all over. So good.
                I5 9600KF, 32GB, 1070, CV1, PointCTRL

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by jfri View Post
                  I would say the roll is terrible slow compared to even the other Migs. And the Mig is fighter right ? Then how can it survive in dogfight when turning is so slow ?
                  Regarding the F86 Sabre feeling difficult. Made that judgement only after trying the navigation session a couple of times and found keeping the altitude difficult. Maybe with a bit of more exercise and patient I might change my mind about it.
                  It is a characteristic shared by more than a few Russian fighters of the time, the -17 and -19 also suffered from low roll rates at high speed and it was mainly due to their control system.

                  So if you find those aircraft roll rate slow in the game, it's nothing strange and there is nothing wrong with the way their flight envelops are simulated in the game, they were so in real life.
                  MSI B450 GAMING PLUS MAX AMD Ryzen B450 ATX DDR4 Motherboard, AMD Ryzen 5 3600X, EVGA NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1080 Ti 11GB, 32GB Kit DDR4-3200, 22' Samsung, Oculus Rift CV1. Thrustmaster T.16000M FCS HOTAS.
                  Mirage 2000C, F-15C, Mig-29, A4E.
                  Avatar: Escadron de Chasse 3/3 Ardennes.
                  So far so good...

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by jfri View Post
                    I own the F86 Sabre but found it very difficult to fly as soon as I left the basics like taking off.
                    I understand that Mig 15 is a similar plane. So how is it with regard to quality of content like missions tutorials compared to F86 ? How easy is it to fly and fight in ? I have only had time to try the startup and take off tutorial
                    If you like the F-86, you'll love the MiG-15. It's not the plane, it's the gun. And I'm not talking about the two "little" ones that are only 23mm

                    Actually, with the exception of top speed, the MiG out-performs the Sabre. It has a higher thrust to weight ratio. It will accelerate and climb better, and has a higher sustained turning rate.

                    The F-86, however, has a much better control system. It's very responsive, whereas the MiG's controls will feel a bit 'mushy' to you after flying the Sabre. In short, the MiG is more work to fly, and probably harder to fly well.

                    Both modules are great though and if you already have the F-86 then the MiG-15 is a sure bet!

                    AD
                    Kit:
                    Asus Z170-P, i5-6600k at 4.5 GHz, 1.35V w/ CM Hyper 212 EVO, 2 x 8GB GSkill Ripjaws 4 @ 3000MHz 15-15-15-35, Zotac GTX 1080 Ti AMP Extreme Core Edition, EVGA SuperNova 750 G2 PSU, HP Omen 32" 2560x1440 single screen, Thrustmaster Cougar HOTAS fitted with Leo Bodnar's BU0836A controller.

                    Flying is the art of throwing yourself at the ground, and having all the rules and regulations get in the way!

                    If man was meant to fly, he would have been born with a lot more money!

                    Comment


                      #11
                      That gun makes me come back to this plane every now and then. It's much more rewarding than the GAU-8 - and I like to use it against ground targets. Facing off some IR threats with this is the real challenge. Feels so great when they get those 37mm in the face after failing to shoot you down.

                      And just flying alone is just great. Needs a lot of fuel management here, I could swear the engine guzzles 100l of fuel in less than half a minute if you firewall the throttle down low. You can really watch the fuel gauge needle go down in no time. Has less range than a MiG-29 running on full AB like that. But flying a bit conservative and going up increases the range and uptime vastly.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        These two are such a great match up, so similar, yet so different.

                        Though, I must say, if you though F-86 was difficult, MiG will probably not be what you are looking for.

                        Very broadly:
                        -F-86 has quite a bit better instantenous turn potential, rolls a lot better, dives really well, and has a higher top speed. 6 high fire rate and flat shooting .50 cals, all around the nose, couple with a decent gun sight makes it decently capable at hitting things, but as it stands, they are among the weaker and more frustrating guns in DCS due to damage model being what it is. Visibility out of cockpit is excellent, magnificent, lovely! Her controls are lovely, only when you get close to Mach 1 will you feel roll controls getting real wonky.

                        -MiG-15 has lots of thrust for its weight. Its acceleration is much better, and climb rate is also much better. Also thanks to having lots of power, if fight drags down to a slow speed turnnig contest, MiG can sustain turns better than the Saber. However, her controls are a lot more clunky overall, and requires a good effort from pilot to extract these strengths. Moreover, as your speed gets closer to Mach 1, aircraft's controls will become very sluggish. Also, she's more capricious, as AoA increases, she'll complain and fight you a lot more than the Saber. Guns are a lot different too. 2 x 23mm and 1 x 37mm cannons have less velocity and less fire rate compared to F-86, and gunsight isn't nearly as sophisticated, but when you hit, unlike the Saber's guns, these will obliterate the target. Finally, there's the canopy. From a cursory look from outside, it looks like a similar bubble canopy. This erroneous feeling gets dissipated immediately inside the cockpit. Seems like russians took all the efforts to make visibility as bad as it can be, with very thick framing, as well as a full length strut at the top blocking vision in imporant directions.

                        Then there's air to ground potential:
                        Saber has quite a few options: I love HVAR rockets, because while they do decent damage if you can hit, and Saber can carry up to 16 of them. She also has a sight that can provide some semblance of a (finicky) ccip. Two decent-ish sized bombs can be carried, and saber even has an auto bomb release mode, though I wouldn't say it's good enough for a small point target like a tank. Guns themselves won't do anything against a proper tank, even an older one. But against lighter armor and soft targets, Saber's guns are excellent for strafing.

                        MiG on the other had, can only carry two tiny bombs, 100 kg at most, and you drop them using the force! Not impressive in the least there, but the guns, especially the 37mm is very potent, especially against lighter targets. Probably it's more reliable than even rockets against those.

                        Finally, F-86 can carry a copule of old sidewinders FWIW (not much if you ask me).

                        Normally I tend to be a MiG person, but between these two I must I say enjoy the Saber more. However, MiG is lovely too.
                        Modules:
                        MiG-21Bis, Fw-190D, Bf-109K, P-51D, F-86F, Ka-50, UH-1H, Mi-8MTV2, Hawk T1A, C-101, FC3, A-10C, CA, Mirage 2000C, Gazelle, L-39, MiG-15Bis, F-5E, AJS 37 Viggen, Yak-52, Christen Eagle II, MiG-19, I-16, JF-17, F-14, F/A-18C, Fw-190A8, AV-8B/NA, Spitifre IX

                        Mods:
                        A-4E, MB-339, Edge 540

                        Utility modules:
                        Combined Arms, NS 430 GPS

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Watch this evaluation and comparing with F-86: https://youtu.be/n-_yFydYu1o
                          I mean its a real Evaluation of MiG-15 by USAF
                          Мой позывной в DCS: _SkyRider_
                          Мой канал YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGd..._as=subscriber

                          My callsign on DCS is: _SkyRider_
                          My YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGd..._as=subscriber

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Both of these planes, f86 and mig15 are just a work of art. So much grit and spirit and a joy to dogfight, at least against ai where you can make them rookies if you want. In VR they are my favorite planes but I dont have the f14 yet. I do love the older jets. I would recomend strongly to head over to lockonfiles.com and download "diveplanes" soundmods for f86 and mig15. Makes a big difference in my ears. Goes from rather dull external sounds to awsome.
                            Last edited 10-22-2020, 08:11 AM.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              I will test it in 2 minutes when the sale starts :-)
                              How to achieve high framerates in VR
                              VIC-20@1.108 MHz, onboard GPU, 5KB RAM, μυωπία goggles, Competition Pro HOTAS

                              Comment


                                #16
                                The 50 cals on the F86 is not very powerful and you need many hits to bring down the Mig-15. You usually need only one or two hits with the Mig to take down the Sabre, one with the 37mm.
                                Pentium II 366Mhz - 1GB 266 DDR Ram - GeForce 2 GTS - Seagate Cheetah X15 36GB - Microsoft Sidewinder 3D Pro - Forte VFX1

                                TF-51D - SU-25T - Caucasus

                                Comment


                                  #17
                                  Originally posted by Razor68 View Post
                                  The 50 cals on the F86 is not very powerful and you need many hits to bring down the Mig-15. You usually need only one or two hits with the Mig to take down the Sabre, one with the 37mm.
                                  Yeah, but in a turn fight Sabre has an advantage because it's .50 machine guns have higher muzzle velocity what means it's need less G to pull in the turn to hit the target!
                                  Мой позывной в DCS: _SkyRider_
                                  Мой канал YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGd..._as=subscriber

                                  My callsign on DCS is: _SkyRider_
                                  My YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGd..._as=subscriber

                                  Comment


                                    #18
                                    In the MIG 15 Whenever i don't have the advantage i point the nose straight up and climb like a bat out of hell.The Sabre's simply can't keep up.Use the vertical.
                                    MODULES: A10C Warthog,AJS Viggen,AV8B Harrier,BF109 K4,C101 Aviojet,F14 Tomcat,F16 Viper,F5 Tiger,F86 Sabre,FA18C Hornet,FW190A8,FW190D9,I16 Ishak,JF17 Thunder,KA50 Blackshark,L39 Albatros,Mirage2000C,MI8MVT2,MIG15BIS,MIG19P,MIG21BIS,P51D Mustang,P47D Thunderbolt,SA342 Gazell,SpitfireIX,TF51D,UH1H Huey,Yak52.
                                    OTHER:Flamming cliffs,Combined Arms,WW2 Assets Pack,SuperCarrier.
                                    TERRAINS: Nevada,Caucasus,Normandy,Persian Gulf,Syria.

                                    Comment


                                      #19
                                      Originally posted by fatboy View Post
                                      In the MIG 15 Whenever i don't have the advantage i point the nose straight up and climb like a bat out of hell.The Sabre's simply can't keep up.Use the vertical.
                                      That's exactly it! The Sabre (at least the current DCS version) cannot match the Mig-15 in the vertical. Given its low roll rate, this makes the Mig somewhat of a one-trick-pony, but it sure works. If you have a Sabre on your six, start doing loops. Two or at most three circles later, you will have a guns solution on the Sabre (if he is foolish enough to follow you into the vertical - and the AI always does).

                                      Comment


                                        #20
                                        I use the Mig for ground attacks, it is very good at that with those powerful cannons.
                                        Pentium II 366Mhz - 1GB 266 DDR Ram - GeForce 2 GTS - Seagate Cheetah X15 36GB - Microsoft Sidewinder 3D Pro - Forte VFX1

                                        TF-51D - SU-25T - Caucasus

                                        Comment

                                        Working...
                                        X